| Dr. Alexander Chirila, Position Paper: Publishing with the LSS |
Dear Alexander, Mary Helen, Ruth & Mei Ha (please read this note from Dr. K.--and Alex's "position paper" directly below).
Commitment is not a one-time thing. Commitment is a process of devoting psychic energy to a given line-of-development, gradually increasing the amount of psychic energy investing in a line of development--until one feels there is "no way out:" this is the way things are--and are going to be.
Orion Anderson and I had been sending out Newsletters through an email marketing system for quite some time. We did have an idea of what we were doing or trying to do. However, it was only when Alexander Chirila came onto the scene that we began to systematically define what we were doing--what we wanted to do.
I won't tell you how long ago this was--it was quite a number of years ago. This wasn't only a question of defining a new way of publishing but, particularly for Alex and I, of abandoning "traditional" ways in which scholarly work is published--through journal articles, books, etc. This new way of publishing seemed almost as revolutionary as my ideas.
Slowly but surely, I've committed to this way of publishing--for myself and other scholars. Logically, of course, it's a no-brainer. By virtue of the Newsletter, we reach 1000 people in a single day. More people read an LSS Newsletter than read an article published in a scholarly journal in its lifetime.
When Alex and I first began discussing this project, there still was resistance to this mode of scholarly publishing. Like everything in the Internet world, however, things changed quickly. Soon after LSS got things going, "Academia.Edu" came into being. There was resistance to them as well. Now, most well-known scholars put as much of their publications as possible onto the web. Why wouldn't they if their objective was to have their writings read and known--to have an impact on the development and course of scholarship?
I've published in "refereed" journals. Recently, one of the most famous scholars in the world (a Harvard University Professor) invited me to publish in a prestigious journal. Although I felt guilty about it (I liked the guy), I turned him down.
At the beginning of 2020, I learned that my email marketing service "iContact" was allowing three million sends per year. You heard that correctly. Digitilization, apparently, makes it easy to publish: to get things out into the world (one of the major reasons for the confusion in the world today).
In any case, I went "berserk" (as the Catman used to say): I sent out Newsletters as fast as I could, trying to imprint my ideas in the minds of our "clients" (as I'll call the people who receive the Newsletter). Sometimes I'd send out four Newsletters in a day.
Most of these Newsletters (over 90%) were "redos" of Newsletters I'd already sent out. I edited each of them and made them stronger. After all, no one ever contradicts my ideas or tells me where I'm wrong. So I simply make my ideas stronger. As long as people are reading what I have to say, I'm happy.
But I'm no longer happy with just sending things out. In fact, for the time-being, I'm done with this. We now enter into a new phase. We want to invite people to join us: by writing for the Newsletter and commenting or reflecting on my ideas.
This means building the prestige of this site: making it the center for research on collective forms of violence. I won't go into the methodology for making this happen now. This is prolegomenon: setting a baseline for the next thrust into reality.
Below is Alexander Chirila's position paper. There's been a lot of water under the bridge since then: a great deal of back-and-forth conversation between Alex and I. But the piece stands as written.
Please read it and you'll see how close our efforts in the past few years...have followed based on the propositions Alex set forth "all those years ago."
Best,
Richard K./Dr. K.
|
|
|
|