"I SHALL NOT ENTIRELY DIE" (Horace)

Norman O. Brown on the quest for immortality

Horace celebrates his success: "I have wrought a monument more enduring than bronze, and loftier than the royal accumulation of the pyramids. Neither corrosive rain nor raging wind can destroy it, nor the innumerable sequence of years nor the flight of time. I shall not altogether die.

"I shall not altogether die-the hope of the man who has not lived, whose life has been spent conquering death, whose life has passed into those immortal pages."

"The ambition of civilized man is revealed in the pyramid the achievement of the first modern individualists. In the pyramid repose both the hope of immortality and the fruit of compound interest.

"As Heichelheim showed, the Iron Age, at the end of which we live, democratized the achievements of the Bronze Age (cities, metals, money, writing) and opened up the pursuit of kings (money and immortality) to the average citizen.

"But the inevitable irony redresses the balance in favor of death. Death is overcome on condition that the real actuality of life pass into these immortal and dead things; money is the man; the immortality of an estate or a corporation resides in the dead things which alone endure.

"By the law of the slow return of the repressed, the last stage of history is, as Luther said, the dominion of death in life; the last stage of the polis is, as Mumford said, Nekropolis. Spengler saw in the late city "a metaphysical turn towards death."

Mumford says: "The metropolis is rank with forms of negative vitality. Nature and human nature, violated in this environment, come back in destructive forms. In this mangled state, the impulse to live departs from apparently healthy personalities. The impulse to die supplants it. Is it any wonder that Dr. Sigmund Freud found a death wish at the seat of human activity?"

"Civilized economic activity has this death-defying and deadening structure because economic activity is sustained by psychic energy taking the form of sublimation. All civilized sublimation, and not only the pursuit of money, has this structure.

"Thus in the first of his odes Horace sees poetry as a career, like all careers (trader, soldier, athlete, etc.), basically characterized by self-sacrifice and instinctual renunciation; it is nevertheless worth while if success will enable him "to strike the stars with head sublime."

"And at the end of the third book he celebrates his success: "I have wrought a monument more enduring than bronze, and loftier than the royal accumulation of the pyramids. Neither corrosive rain nor raging wind can destroy it, nor the innumerable sequence of years nor the flight of time. I shall not altogether die." I shall not altogether die-the hope of the man who has not lived, whose life has been spent conquering death, whose life has passed into those immortal pages."