|
Scott Atran's Theory of Sacred Values
and the Devoted Actor

Scott Atran Anthropologist · Cognitive scientist · University of Michigan: Research on nationalism, religious commitment, political violence and willingness to die. Scott Atran is particularly relevant to the work of the Foundation for the Study of Political Pathology. He has conducted empirical research on why people become willing to kill and die for political, religious, and national causes. His central concept is the devoted actor.
Atran's argument is that people may become so deeply committed to sacred values and collective identities that ordinary calculations of personal advantage cease to govern their behavior. They will risk everything, including their lives, for what they believe in. His work is especially important because he attempts to investigate this phenomenon scientifically, through field research, interviews, surveys, and psychological experiments.
- Sacred values: Atran defines sacred values as commitments that people regard as nonnegotiable. Examples include: God and religious principles. National independence. Homeland and territory. Political freedom. Collective honor and identity. People who regard something as sacred do not necessarily evaluate it in terms of material costs and benefits. They may refuse money, security, or other advantages rather than surrender what they regard as sacred. Atran's important observation is that sacred values can motivate people to accept enormous personal costs, including death.
- Identity fusion: A second central concept is identity fusion. This occurs when individuals experience their personal identity as inseparable from the identity of a collective group. The distinction between I and We becomes blurred. The individual experiences the group almost as an extended family. Atran argues that this psychological fusion can produce extraordinary willingness to sacrifice for other members of the group. Importantly, people may be willing to die not simply for an abstract cause but for their comrades, whom they experience as brothers and sisters.
- The devoted actor: The combination of sacred values and identity fusion produces what Atran calls the devoted actor. Such individuals may: Fight against overwhelming odds. Refuse opportunities to surrender. Accept almost certain death. Kill and die for their comrades. Reject material incentives that might otherwise encourage compromise. Atran's research demonstrates that devotion can sometimes outweigh conventional military advantages. A relatively weak group whose members possess extraordinary commitment may resist a materially superior opponent. His research on ISIS, Palestinian-Israeli conflict, and other conflicts illustrates this phenomenon.
- Why people sacrifice themselves: Atran's explanation is especially interesting because he challenges the assumption that people sacrifice themselves primarily because they have been persuaded that doing so is rational or beneficial. Instead, sacrifice may satisfy profound psychological needs: The need to belong to something larger than oneself. The need to experience one's existence as meaningful. The desire for glory and heroic recognition. The need to defend a sacred collective identity. The desire to participate in something transcending individual mortality. In his 2025 article, "What Sustains Wars: Will to Fight Versus Military Might," Atran explicitly connects willingness to fight with the human quest for existential significance.
- Atran and Koenigsberg—similarities and differences: This is where the comparison becomes particularly valuable. Atran and Koenigsberg explain why people become willing to sacrifice themselves, and the psychological and cultural function of sacrificial death.
Sacred values motivate extraordinary commitment. Death helps establish the reality of sacred values. Identity fusion makes individuals experience the group as part of themselves. Identification with the nation makes the imagined collective body more important than the biological individual. Sacrifice provides meaning, belonging, and significance. Sacrifice provides verification of the truth and supreme value of ideology.
I would emphasize one distinction above all: Atran explains the willingness to sacrifice. Koenigsberg asks what the production of sacrifice accomplishes for the society and ideology that demand it.
- An important connection to the decline of sacrificial nationalism: Atran's work also raises an interesting question concerning Koenigsberg's thinking about contemporary America. If sacred values and identity fusion are important determinants of willingness to die for a group, what happens when individuals no longer experience their nation as a sacred object with which they are deeply fused?
- Atran's framework suggests that willingness to fight may weaken when people no longer perceive a compelling sacred cause or experience sufficiently strong collective identification. His 2025 analysis explicitly discusses the absence of these conditions among people who do not become devoted actors. This offers a possible empirical avenue for investigating Koenigsberg's hypothesis about the decline of sacrificial nationalism.
- I would organize the relationship between Atran and Koenigsberg as follows: Atran provides particularly valuable empirical support for investigating the psychological mechanisms Koenigsberg describes theoretically. But Atran does not himself establish Koenigsberg's Law of Sacrifice: his principal research question is the motivation of devoted actors, not the social function of producing death.
A particularly interesting question to put to Atran: If people are willing to die because they regard their nation as sacred, might the actual deaths of these people also serve to establish and perpetuate the sacred character of the nation? That question identifies precisely where Atran's research and Koenigsberg's theory meet.
|